Tata Sierra EV Gets 5-Star Bharat NCAP Rating: How Safe Is It Compared to Rivals?

Tata Motors’ latest electric SUV has achieved a strong result in terms of safety. The Tata Sierra EV has secured a 5-star safety rating in the Bharat NCAP crash tests, with the electric SUV scoring 30.62 out of 32 points in Adult Occupant Protection (AOP) and 45 out of 49 points in Child Occupant Protection (COP).

Join Our Youtube Channel to stay updated with daily car & bike news instantly! 

An important point about this result is that while the top-end Empowered A 75kWh QWD variant of the Sierra EV was used for crash testing, the Bharat NCAP 5-star rating is applicable to all variants of the SUV. This provides reassurance in terms of safety credentials to buyers considering entry-level and mid-level variants as well.

However, it’s important to understand the detailed crash-test scores that accompany the overall 5-star rating. The Sierra EV performed well in the frontal and side-impact tests, but received an ‘OK’ rating in the side pole impact test.

Also Read: Tata Sierra Legend Series Launched at Rs. 11.99 Lakh, 18 New Variants Added

Tata Sierra EV Bharat NCAP Adult Occupant Protection: 30.62/32

Tata Sierra EV undergoing side-impact crash testing at the Bharat NCAP facility, highlighting its 5-star safety rating.

In the Adult Occupant Protection category, the Tata Sierra EV scored 30.62 out of 32 points. In this category, the SUV achieved 14.62/16 points in the frontal offset deformable barrier test and a full 16/16 points in the side movable deformable barrier test.

In the frontal offset test, the driver and co-driver’s head, chest, pelvis, and thighs received a ‘Good’ protection rating. However, both occupants’ tibiae received ‘Adequate’ protection, while the driver’s feet received ‘Marginal’ protection.

In the side movable deformable barrier test, the SUV provided ‘Good’ protection for all crucial body regions. This result highlights the Tata Sierra EV strong performance in side-impact protection.

In the side pole impact test, however, the SUV received an ‘OK’ rating. Therefore, it’s important to consider the individual crash-test assessments alongside the 5-star overall result.

Tata Sierra EV Child Occupant Protection: 45/49

Tata Sierra EV during a Bharat NCAP crash test, demonstrating side-impact protection and vehicle safety performance.

In the Child Occupant Protection category, the Sierra EV scored 45 out of 49 points. In this category, the SUV achieved a full 24/24 points in dynamic crash tests.

Bharat NCAP assessed rear-facing 18-month-old and 3-year-old child dummies. Both child dummies scored 8/8 points in the frontal crash test and 4/4 points in the side crash test.

The Sierra EV also scored a full 12/12 points in the Child Restraint System (CRS) installation assessment. However, it scored 9 out of 13 points in the vehicle assessment category, resulting in an overall child protection score of 45/49.

These results are important for family buyers, as child occupant protection depends not only on crash-test performance, but also on the ability to properly install child seats in the vehicle.

Also Read: Tata Aeris Sales Cross 6,400 Units in Two Months, Beats Honda Amaze in October

Tata Sierra EV vs Rivals: Safety Scores Compared

Compared to Bharat NCAP results, the Tata Sierra EV’s performance is close to that of some key electric SUV rivals in its segment. The Maruti e Vitara, Mahindra BE 6 Sporteq, and VinFast VF6 have also achieved 5-star safety ratings.

Electric SUVAdult Protection (32)Child Protection (49)
Tata Sierra EV30.6245
Maruti e Vitara31.4943
Mahindra BE 6 Sporteq31.9745
VinFast VF627.1344.41

In adult occupant protection, the Mahindra BE 6 Sporteq leads the table with 31.97 points, while the Maruti e Vitara scores 31.49 points. The Sierra EV’s 30.62-point result is also close behind.

In child occupant protection, the Sierra EV scores 45 points, equal to the Mahindra BE 6 Sporteq’s score. The Maruti e Vitara scores 43 points, while the VinFast VF6 scores 44.41 points.

This comparison clearly shows that the Sierra EV offers competitive safety performance among its rivals. However, an SUV cannot be declared safe in every situation based solely on numerical scores, as vehicle structure, restraint systems, and driving conditions are also important factors in real-world safety, in addition to crash-test performance.

All Tata Sierra EV Variants Get the 5-Star Rating

Tata Sierra EV Bharat NCAP 5-star safety rating certificate showing adult occupant protection score of 30.62/32 and child occupant protection score of 45/49.

An important aspect of this result is the applicability of the rating. The top-end Empowered A 75kWh QWD variant was used in Bharat NCAP testing, but the 5-star rating is applicable to all variants of the Sierra EV.

This means that even if buyers choose a lower variant of the SUV, Bharat NCAP’s announced safety rating coverage will remain relevant to them. This detail is particularly important, as buyers are often concerned about the differences in safety equipment between entry-level and top-end variants.

Auto India Daily Verdict

The Tata Sierra EV 5-star Bharat NCAP result is a positive development for the company’s electric SUV portfolio. The SUV demonstrated strong crash-test performance, scoring 30.62/32 points in adult occupant protection and 45/49 points in child occupant protection.

Compared to rivals, the Sierra EV’s child protection score is comparable to the Mahindra BE 6 Sporteq, while the adult protection score is also competitive. The ‘OK’ rating in the side pole impact test should also be taken into account during the detailed safety assessment.

Most importantly, the 5-star rating is applicable to all Sierra EV variants, even though the crash testing was done on the top-end Empowered A 75kWh QWD variant. While this is a meaningful safety credential for family buyers, variant-wise safety equipment and overall ownership requirements should also be considered in the final purchasing decision.

Alos Read: Tata Sierra Dark vs Creta Knight: Price, Specs, Design, Engine & Interior Compared